90 Points "Light yellow. Bright, high-pitched aromas of orange zest, ginger, white flowers and white pepper. Racy and focused, with sappy citrus and orchard fruit flavors picking up smokiness and a touch of peach pit with air. Shows good energy on the refreshingly brisk, linear, long finish."
91 Points "A beautifully integrated wine that shows richness, even a touch of toasty age to go with apple and intense acidity. The acidity shows so well against the rich backdrop of ripe fruits and a final edgy texture."
90 Points Best Buy "There's tension in this wine between the lime of white earth and lime citrus. The flavors are pale, chalky, hinting at white mushrooms, freshly dug potatoes and spice. Reserve wines lend this depth, while the wine's freshness keeps it mouthwatering. For aperitifs, or a plate of Comté."
92 Points "The NV Brut Premier is a gorgeous wine that stands head and shoulders above the vast majority of wines in its price range. Apparently, it is quite possible to make great Champagne that doesn’t cost a small fortune. Ripe pears, smoke, spices, dried flowers and herbs are some of the many nuances that emerge from the glass. The Brut Premier shows lovely mid-palate depth and fabulous overall balance. Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lecaillon has done it again. This is a fabulous Brut Premier."
92 Points "A pretty note of apple blossom runs through this elegant Champagne, which is bright and juicy, offering flavors of green and yellow apple, tangerine and ground ginger, with a hint of graham cracker. Shows lovely texture, with a mouthwatering finish..."
90 Points "The NV Brut Premier is a soft, creamy wine that captures the essence of the house style in its refined mousse, precise aromas and flavors and compelling overall balance. ...Year after year, this is one of Champagne’s most reliably outstanding entry-level wines."
Highly Recommended "Lively pinpoint bubbles; crisp and lively; creamy; intense cherry and raspberry flavors"
90 Points "The firm, toasty richness of reserve wines lends depth and structure to this nonvintage brut. The lemon-curd fruitiness is round, edged by mineral and wood tones. For aperitifs."
90-92 Points 2009 Blend: "This shows lovely balance in a rich, round style I find highly appealing. The Brut Premier looks very promising at this stage."
3 stars "It is a perennial favorite of mine...It was ripe and rich, yet showed the balance and elegance I’ve come to expect in Roederer Champagnes. ...Ripe and rich, yet balanced, with lingering flavors of lemon, flowers and chalk."
90 points "Reserve wines add rich, toasty complexity to this blend. The fruit flavors have a red cast, the structure transforming the juiciness of the wine into a mouthwatering, soft line."
89 points "The NV Brut Premier is a gorgeous Champagne at this level. Fresh, perfumed, zesty fruit emerges from this accessible, medium-bodied Champagne. The Brut Premier reveals an irresistible, immediate personality, with terrific balance. It is without question one of the finest NV Champagnes readers are likely to come across as well as one of the best relative values in the region."
91 points, #95 of To "Light and lively, featuring apple, toast, ginger and light vanilla flavors. Balanced and on the dry side, with a creamy texture and a lingering butter pastry aftertaste."
An Old World "Roederer's basic brut Champagne is luscious, with aromas of peaches and fresh-baked brioche."
91 points "Although this tastes younger than some recent bottlings of this great non-vintage, it is still a fine wine. Its apple flavors meld effortlessly with citrus, grapefruit zest, and just a touch of toast to show the depth of flavor that will emerge after a few more months in bottle."
Recommended "The non-vintage Louis Roederer Brut Premier ($47) is more delicate, with citrus and mineral nuances."
"The Louis Roederer Champagne house seems to be on a roll. Every one of their offerings is fantastic this year: ...the nonvintage Brut Premier."
90 points "A clean and supple blend of red fruit with paler tones of pear and cherimoya, this has a soft middle balanaced by the tension of its acidity. It continues to open with air, round, gentle and energized. An elegant aperitif."
89 points "The NV Brut Premier is a pretty, perfumed offering redolent of pears, greens apples and flowers. This medium-bodied, refined NV Champagne offers excellent length and a crisp, refreshing finish with notes of sweetness that linger on the close."
16.75 / 20 "Bright, clean with finesse. Very elegant, classy, beautifully balanced wine. Acidity and attack very impressive. Drink now."
92 Points "This Roederer nonvintage seems to be getting drier, bringing out more of the green fruits and less creamy character. It works well here because the wine has some bottle age, giving a beautifully balanced wine that has great class and elegance."
90 points "A bouquet of fresh baguette and toasted barrel with a hint of chalkiness. Very citrusy on the palate with lemon and lime flavors laced with youthful acidity. Zesty, dry finish has a steely edge."
88 points "Light gold with a fine bead. Pungent, herb-accented citrus and pear aromas are complemented by zesty spices and minerals. Round and toasty, offering deep pear and apple flavors, a pliant texture and a lush but incisive finish, with echoes of toast and minerals."
Champagne "A" List: "Nice yeasty nose. Quite crisp, with great citrus vitality. Ripe grapes with real fruit tastes, a spiky lemon character and a long, lemon-lime, very dry finish."
Critics Platinum Distinguished as a wine that "delivers a profound dimension either for overall quality, value, or both"
90 Points "A robust Brut, Roederer blends in 10 to 20 percent of reserve wines to give this a rich balance of freshness and maturity. The broad red fruit flavors have the rose cast of a Dungeness crab shell, ready for crab season this winter."
92 Points "A classic nonvintage Champagne, Brut Premier is also a yardstick by which others are measured. In the case of this bottle, that yardstick is working well: the palate is rich and creamy, there is a maturity along with great fruit and elegance. Best as an aperitif wine, this could also go with light foods."
91 Points "Minerally, flinty scents of apple, lemon, mixed grains and almond are focused and fresh. Bright, youthful flavors of lemon peel, Granny Smith apple and chalk. Dry, toasty finish."
4 Stars "Unusually, the 2001-based cuvee has 20% reserve wine from the 2000, as well as 10% older reserve wine. Elegance, finesse and complexity are the Roederer hallmarks and it will age very well over a number of years."
Copyright © 2012 MMD USA, Inc., All Rights Reserved